Mutharika’s recent appointments under microscope

Peter Mutharika

A law expert has questioned the manner of President Peter Mutharika’s appointment of four High Court Judges, suggesting that the appointments seemed to have been made in a hurry.

On Thursday, Secretary to the Office of the President and Cabinet George Mkondiwa announced that Mutharika has appointed Joseph Chigona, Dorothy de Grabrielle, Ruth Chinangwa and George Bakuwa as high court judges.

Peter Mutharika
Peter Mutharika made some notable appointments.

Mkondiwa said the appointments were effective on the day of announcement, October 13 2016.

On presidential appointments, Section 90 of the Constitutions of the Republic of Malawi says “decisions of the President shall be expressed in writing under his or her signature” and “the signature of the President on any instrument shall be confirmed by the Public Seal.”

But writing in his blog, legal expert Sunduzwayo Madise questioned the way the appointments have been made considering that for Mutharika to have made the appointment while in New York, the Presidential Office need to have carried the whole Public Seal and Presidential Stationary with them to America – something which he found odd.   

Sunduzwayo Madise
Sunduzwayo Madise questions the idea on the appointments.

He also found it hard to understand why the president made the appointments on Thursday in New York yet he is expected back in the country today as government earlier announced.  

“Why the rush? In any event, the appointed Judges cannot assume office unless they have taken oath in the presence of the President. So the personal presence of the President is crucial both to ensure that the statutory instrument is valid and that the oath of office has been taken,” wrote Madise.

Meanwhile, a message circulating on social media which Malawi24 could not independently verify claims that the appointment of the four judges has been done by Democratic Progressive Party politburo in a bid to bar Vice President Saulos Chilima from becoming acting president if Mutharika who is reportedly sick is declared incapacitated.

“Determined to wrestle power through courts, the emergency cabinet meeting that was convened a few days ago at Sanjika Palace chaired by DPP Vice President, George Chaponda resolved to start legal battles to fight the constitutional provision under section 87 subsection 1 which provides conditions for the Vice President of the country to assume Presidency where a seating President is deemed incapacitated,” reads part of the message.



  1. chilipo chomwe ife a Malawi tinayamikirapo kuti ichi ndiye president achita cha bwino? Thats why kutukuka kumativuta even at community level

  2. chilipo chomwe ife a Malawi tinayamikirapo kuti ichi ndiye president achita cha bwino? Thats why kutukuka kumativuta even at community level

  3. nzodabwitsatu kkkk nthawi zonse amangoti “chala mmwamba nde zinayenda bwanji osatero aaa ok tizizamuwona mma representatives to the people during important conferences akapanda kutero nde mmmmm mzatumeko ineo ku USA kukafufuza bwino za Mr APM

  4. Amalawi chachilendo ndichiyani,kukhala msogoleli sikuthandauza kuti sangadwale,iye ndi.unthu monga aliyense Ali ,monga msogoleli tikuyenela kukhudzidwa ndin thu.amalawi tidziopa mulungu thinking like Malawian with no any party,let’s play for him if not possible,ambuye amutso golele pomwe Ali my vutoli,am sorry for that.

  5. The four judges must not continue with their appointed posts coz they are not chosen for just reasons

  6. The president is being shosen by people!! And the judges and other officials they are there!! Evin. The presidential term finished!! But the problem is the poor. The ignorantic. Is the people!! For the politicians are gaining? ASK ABRO!!.

  7. You DPP fools, know that Malawi is not your estate where you can change constitution illegally….you will be arrested with your foolishness.

  8. This is really unusual anyway if he is not coming today then hey.The truth of the matter is that we are a bad people that’s why we have a bad president, he is the true reflection of us.Lets change ourselves the time is now.

  9. Hello friends, my name is Susan Mwanza this a testimony of how i got cure fully from HIV/AIDS, i was diagnose with HIV/AIDS FIVE year ago, i contacted a doctor who later gave me some treatment, but it was like the treatment he gave to me were not enough i was desperately in need of something that will get rid of the deadly virus from my body, my life was miserable i lost my job and few of my friends, not quit long a faithful friend of mine came to me one afternoon telling about what he saw on net a testimony of how DR Abumen cured people from various kind of virus including Herpes, i was like this is a scam, but he old me he believe in what he had read on line’ he told me he will contact DR Abumen on my behalf and he did so, after some days he receive a parcel containing DR Abumen herbal medication, he present it before me to use it, that when am cured i should pay back the money it cost her while negotiating for the medicine, after taking the medicine for some days according to DR Abumen instruction, then i decided to go for check up and i was happy to see that no sign of the virus was found in my body, i am very thankful to my friend, if you are having a similar problem or you need his help you can reach him on ([email protected]) or you can call or chat with him on whattsapp through +2347085071418, please share to save life.

    1. Ndiosafunikira kwenkweni or atamwalira palibe choluza wava taona apapo iweyo ukuvutika iyeyo wadya misonkho yako ku america osamakhala opusa wava aise zinatha kale zoponderezana ngati umadya nao uli nd tsoka zimatiwawa wava

    2. Iwe sindimadya nawo ine bt l always mind my own busines l work in order to eat come to home u can see l never sit a lways work hard so dat l can get something to feed my family l don’t depend on hand outs

    3. Komano osamaikira kumbuyo anthu oponderezawa chilichose chili nd nthawi mulungu amalanga yekha sadzalora mtundu wake kuvutika ndi kagulu kochepa kaya umadya zako othokoze mulungu pa ntchito anakupatsa dont go behind on dat evil pple wava

  10. Is there anything else best that the president shall do to please everyone? certainly not! Be careful with these so called experts as their emotions may drive their professionalism.

Comments are closed.